This is the ONE Downside to Going Gray from Dyed Hair
Ever since I went gray from dark brunette dyed hair, something strange happens to me on a fairly regular basis…and I would be willing to bet money that it’s happened to some of you, too.
Actually, scratch that – I KNOW it has happened to many of you because you’ve emailed me about it.
What happens to me appears to be a fairly common problem among silver-haired women, although (from what I’ve gathered), the problem seems to occur more often to those of us who live in the U.S.A.
(I’m not a cultural anthropologist, so I won’t bore you by trying to figure out exactly WHY it happens more in the U.S.A. than other countries, but I suspect it’s because Americans in general tend to be a bit more chatty and open with each other than some other cultures. Which can be great, but not always…)
I recorded a video all about it, which you can see below – or you can keep reading if you prefer to do so!
Want to Save this Article?
Enter your email below & I'll send it straight to your inbox!
Anyway, here’s the scenario:
I go to a party, or a gathering of some kind, with women I haven’t seen in a while.
And then the compliments start. (This is NOT the downside – this is the good part! And believe me, I really appreciate it and don’t take it for granted).
The comments generally start off nice, like this:
“Hey, wow – your hair looks great!”
“I love your natural hair!”
“Your gray hair looks fabulous!” and,
“Look at you, with your gorgeous silver hair.”
Yay, compliments – this is great! I’m feeling pretty good right now!
But then we move on to the next (seemingly inevitable) phase of the conversation:
“You are so brave, I could never do that.”
(Well, I’m not rescuing babies from a burning hospital – I just got sick of dyeing my hair)
“I’m too young to go gray.”
(Umm, lady you’re the same age (or older) than me)
“I could never do it – I care too much about how I look.”
(OKAY.. I guess I don’t give a flying fig about how I look??)
“Your gray hair is pretty but mine is ugly.”
(You actually can’t tell until all the dye is cut off, but also …what the heck am I supposed to say to this?)
Then, no matter how much I try to steer the conversation away from my gray hair, or gray hair in general, it ends up with my female friends / colleagues / acquaintances explaining to me in great detail why going gray isn’t the right choice for them.
Which is fine, but see – I never asked.
I KNOW going gray from dyed hair is still a non-conformist choice.
I would never pressure anybody to go gray, and I never evangelize about it to people because it is SUCH a personal decision.
The only time I give advice or guidance about gray hair is when people ask me.
But I keep getting drawn into these kinds of conversations and to be honest, it’s draining.
I just want to be with my friends and have a nice time, and not have my hair be the main topic of conversation (and controversy).
Please note that this article may contain affiliate links. You can read my full disclosure at the bottom of the page.
Why Does This Happen?
I finally figured out why this happens:
When we make choices that are unusual or go against the cultural norm, some people see that as a rebuke.
Our decision to go silver puts these types of people on the defensive.
Even if we never said ONE WORD about our gray hair to them, the very act of BEING a naturally silver-haired woman feels like a slap in the face to them and it makes them feel like we are questioning THEIR choices.
And that’s why they get defensive and start explaining their choice not to go gray to us, even if we never asked them.
It’s so odd as I’m not that type of person – and I bet many of you aren’t, too.
So it’s hard to get into their mindset. But it IS a mindset that many people have.
I first encountered this mindset when I used cloth diapers for my infants.
I didn’t care what other people did with their babies, but for my babies, I wanted to use cloth diapers.
When I’d change my baby’s diaper at a mommy get-together, inevitably someone would notice my son’s cloth diapers and then immediately launch a defense of why they chose to use disposable.
If they were really feeling heated, I’d get an earful about why I was wrong to use cloth (say what?)
I had to hear about it ALL THE TIME even though I never ONCE brought up the topic myself.
It was annoying!
Do I have any words of wisdom on how to handle this?
Not really. Because nothing really works (believe me, I’ve tried everything).
The only thing I can think of is to pretend to start choking on crackers or something (!!) next time this happens, as I think that only a major emergency could stop this type of convo in its tracks.
But at least WE know that, despite this aggravation, we are happy with OUR choice and get to reap the rewards of healthier, unique hair.
I’d love to hear your thoughts or comments on this!
Leave your comment below, and make sure to tell me what country you are from. Thanks!
Please do me a favor and share this post to social media, as it helps me grow my audience and spread the word about our Silver Revolution! And remember to subscribe to my YouTube Channel and Pinterest Feed for more gray hair tips and product recommendations. Thanks!
Hi Katie,
I’ve been following your posts and having done my ‘research’ on going gray, started my journey in November ’23.
As the primary caregiver of elderly parents , now parent, one thing I’ve retained over the years is experimenting with my hair- mostly styles and cuts!
I’ve been coloring my hair off and on since 2018 , used henna , then brushed up the roots with color etc. But your journey and those of other silver sisters made me want to explore what my actual hair color was. I’m brunette btw.
Anyway I digress. The real critic I feel is the one in the mirror.
And so long as one is easy with oneself, why give a fig what anyone else thinks?
Having said that, so far the younger generation – 20’s- are like oh your hair looks totally cool. While the ‘older’ ( heh!) set gives me these ‘are you nuts’ looks.
I am 55 , live in India , am single – never been married – , and chucked up a high voltage career to look after my parents. So after so many digressions from these so called societal rules , what’s hair color?
Yes, there are days when I don’t feel too great about the salt but then I look at my colored hair pics and say no way…
I can be anyone I want to be and do not require random nosy parkers to point out their perceptions of my innumerable ‘flaws’.
Love your posts. They inspire me a lot . And yes, I do appreciate your challenge with retaining your gray whilst looking for a new job. But I’m sure you’ll find a great way ahead!
Keep going strong and shine on.
To all the ladies who’ve written above , I admire your grit and spunk.
Since I don’t get out much except for important jobs, maybe I’ve been spared the social jabs . But I hope , that by the time that happens, I would have grown totally into what I feel best about doing for myself – on the hair front and otherwise as well.
With lots of love and best wishes,
Bobby
It really annoys me when people say I am brave for going grey at my age (I’m 39), like you say. It’s not like I’m rescuing people from burning buildings!
And usually, the brave comment is followed by I couldn’t do it. I usually just respond with ‘i guess it’s each to their own, isn’t
it!’ Interestingly, I find most of the negative comments come from women of a similar age to me; I get loads of compliments from older women and even teenagers.
I’m Uk based
Excellent article delivered with great humor! The thing that always gets me about this situation is that the friend/stranger/whoever who is saying this stuff to you NEVER considers that you might think their dyed hair looks like crap. Truly. This is not the nicest comment but I’m tempted to come back and say; “And I think YOU are brave for sporting a hair color that is so truly not natural and does nothing for you.”
Snarky rant ending now!
I love that!!
This is amazingly accurate! The words people say are exactly what you wrote and in that order! I am new to being gray to lots of people who only see me once a year or even less and I was rather shocked at how much they all talked about my decision to go gray without me ever bringing it up. I am 58 and have colored my hair since I was in my mid twenties. Decided in March of 2022 to just stop and let it grow out naturally. This article is great because I thought it was me that brought this out in these friends and family – so nice to know this is how people react. It’s not me! When I have had friends, customers, etc. go gray I never said a word to them about it – not a word. To me that would have been rude and none of my business. Could not believe people feel they get to discuss this as though they get a vote on it, as though it matters to them if I color my hair or not. The only other person it might matter to is my husband or maybe my children if I had any. I don’t get why they care – but your explanation makes sense to me. This goes along with something that is not related to gray hair but something I struggle with all the time – covid. I have a long history of chronic illness and have fought long and hard daily to manage myself. My doctors have made it clear that it’s pretty much a 90% chance if I get covid I will be right back to the beginning, retriggering all those symptoms, back in bed, in pain, hardly knowing my own name. So my husband take precautions and we wear masks if we must be at a group gathering – like a funeral or wedding. We work outdoors, we see our customers outdoors because we are farmers so it’s not that hard for us to live like this, except when we have to interact in social situations. It’s just like the gray hair – everyone thinks they get to way in on our decision and to tell us what to do and not do. Perfect strangers included. I just don’t get it – I really don’t. Why do they care if I have a mask on or not? It is really beyond me. I am a very busy person and maybe that’s why I don’t spend time and energy analyzing others and making judgements about them. But your explanation for the gray hair comments fits for the covid pressure/facemask issue…it’s the same thing. Thanks for your article!
You’re welcome, Marianne! And I’m sorry you have to deal with that re: your masks. What is wrong with people? I think you’re right – they must not have a very busy life (or much else to think about).
Hi Katie! Been following you since lockdown first happened in 2020 and I wanted to seize the day and stop all the nonsense with dyeing. Especially since it was months before we could even get in to see a hairdresser! So the hard work was done for me. I did the gray blending route although I did look into the dye strip method. Because I had bangs I just didn’t think that would work for me. Anyway, most people ignore my hair, as if I look exactly the same as I used to! hahaha A couple of friends have said they like it, one of my coworkers did the whole “you’re so brave route” and I was like wow, did you just say that. I will admit that I’ve noticed women’s hair now more than ever, and some of the bad dye jobs just make me cringe. I also had a rude man ask me “what did you do to your hair” to which I replied “what did you do with your manners”. hahahah It felt good I hate to say. Anyway, I live in Ontario Canada. I’ve never had total strangers ask me where I get my hair done because they love it, but I’ve also not experienced much negative. So neutral here. After reading what you wrote maybe that’s a good thing.
Hi, Ilene – yes, I think no response or a neutral response is better than intrusive questions/rude comments for sure. I love what you said to that man – good for you!
hey katie,you know in my case I haven’t recieved any negative comments on my hair,its been the opposite,me gray looks like light lites,and so natural,I just love it,besides silver is in fashion now,everyone wants this color,so embrace it like I did.yours looks great,bye Elizabeth
thanks, Elizabeth! I’m glad you’ve avoided these type of comments.
USA- I enjoyed coloring my hair for many many years. Decided to go gray prior to 2020. My silvers were solid and for me I knew it was time. My hair is pretty silver white and I’m not one to like any attention but most people were the same – wow love your hair ❤️ snd in same breath they couldn’t do it. I learned to just embrace it as I did ditching the dye. My only comment usually is thank you. I was just ready to embrace my natural color. If they were more defending not going gray – I just comment it’s your hair. No wrong answer. I started fraying at 16. Im soon to be 59. Age is just a number. If I look old than great – I’ve earned it with all that comes with age.
Katie you were and still are an inspiration. I see more younger woman going natural. It’s just a different version of blond hair 😎❤️
thanks, Irene!
New Zealand- and I was chuckling all the way through this video.. “ I could never!” Hahaha- over and over- all these things. And you’re so right, I never bring it up, or care what other people do. In fact, I try really hard to not comment on a person’s appearance in general. I have three daughters and my goal has been to focus on who they are as a person as opposed to looks and outward facing things- so I am constantly modeling that. Clothes, hair, shoes, a trend, the next right thing or gadget- all of it… I try to focus on behaviours. For me though, I always get “the hair- how did you do it, when did you do it, it’s so pretty! But I could never!” Sigh…. I’ve done a lot of things in my life, but being grey seems to be a highlight. Hahaha- Oh well, it is a good starter conversation.
I’m 42 and have never dyed my hair, and I’m looking forward to continuing to have natural hair (recently discovered it was wavy/curly not just frizzy! Woo!). But I really connected to the way people defend their decisions NOT to go gray. I have conversations like that all the time about homeschooling! Homeschooling is a personal decision, works with our lifestyle/life goals, etc etc. I’m not twisting your arm to homeschool your only child—school is probably a better place for him! No, I’m not more patient than you—my kids push me to the brink weekly! Ha! They feel they have to defend their choices when I never questioned their choices in the first place. Fortunately, once that’s out of the way, we do get on to talk about other things. Cloth diapers, bottle-feeding, homeschool, private school, public school, going vegan, raising your own beef, career change, going grey, getting a puppy (love the commenter who mentioned that!),… it is somehow all related to them, when it never was an attack on them. Thanks for your insight!!
I am doing the gradual change method. I still have a fair amount of dark blonde to light brown in the back. From the USA. Thank you for sharing your story and tips. Kathy
You’re welcome!
Thank you for this! I’m in my early 40s and 2 years dye-free. My hair is long salt and pepper with a LOT of salt, but I’ve had greying hair since my teens. It’s wild what my female friends say about my decision to grow my natural hair. The conversations I’ve had come straight from your script! I live on the other side of the world to you, but I guess people are the same everywhere. I would never judge another woman’s decisions regarding her appearance, as we experience plenty of pressure elsewhere. But… the longer I grow out my hair, the more happy I am with my decision. My dyed hair was starting to look wiggish (if you know, you know…) and I feel much more beautiful now.
I’m so glad you feel lovely and happy with your natural hair, that’s all that matters – and it makes it easier to shrug off those annoying comments.
I’m 58 and from the Midwest in the US. My husband supported me the whole way; primarily because it’s a lot cheaper than hair appointments every four weeks to cover my roots 😃 My hairstylist had always told me that when I decided to go natural, my hair would be beautiful since the roots she saw were white and silver. The one downside is I miss chatting and laughing with her for the 90 minutes or so I was in the salon. The one person who freaked out was my older sister who said I would look old. She had a friend grow hers out but didn’t do much with respect to conditioning, cutting, toning, styling, etc. I explained growing your natural color out doesn’t mean you abandon hair care. A few things motivated me to make the change: retirement, surviving breast cancer, and, a month long vacation without a hair appointment. I’ve heard the “brave”, “it’s not right for me”, etc. “Brave” makes me want to giggle because, well, it’s hair that I could color if I hated my natural color. I understand that for working women it may not be the right time due to potential age discrimination, which was a deterrent for me when I was working. Today, I love it when my style conscious nieces and nephews tell me how how chic my hair looks.
I’m experiencing age discrimination as I look for a new job, now with it especially, as I’m only a year in just at the point that it’s obviously a choice to grow it out and not just missed hair appts.
It isn’t fun but I don’t want to color it again so I am trying to make sure my own attitude is good. It’s made me want to be healthier and take better care of myself physically and emotionally it’s an interesting journey for sure!
I’m fully transitioned and totally love my long gray hair. I’m in southern USA and very few of my friends are natural.
One acquaintance mentioned about how brave I was. I just laughed and said something about how I’m not brave, I’m afraid of many things but gray hair or others’ expectations don’t qualify.
When I told some friends about my plans to stop dyeing, a male asked what my husband thought. I laughed and said, “ He’s gray! What’s he going to say? But I hope he loves it, but if not….he’ll get over it.” PS: he does!
A bald coworker, who i really liked, saw me after i was going gray and said, “Why?” as he pointed to his head. I replied, “You’re giving me hair advice?” He said, “Touché” and we both laughed.
That’s about all the comments I got except for the positive ones. A couple have since followed my path but even the ones who say they love mine are afraid of the grow out stage. If asked, I offer a few suggestions and direct them to some FB pages. But that’s it. I don’t care what others do with their hair. I kind of like being the unicorn in the room!!
Hi Katie. I’ve been thinking about this one…..
About 8 years ago I moved from London (England) to Penzance in Cornwall (bottom left of the UK where the land meets the sea) I was 60 years old and had waist length auburn hair – no idea where my natural red hair met the bottled red, as like most of us, those flipping roots needed attention every 3 weeks…year in, year out.
Anyway, when the first lockdown happened, I found your blog, laughed out loud for the first time in ages, and decided to embrace my natural, whatever it was that I was hiding.
And these are my thoughts so far….
If I had not moved out of the Capital City, and all that rat race, competition/insecure, must keep up mind set, it probably would never have occurred to me to stop colouring my hair. I would have carried on until I dropped dead sporting a sparse, bright orange, ridiculous hair do. Exactly like my Great Aunty Queenie.
But, having moved away, reached a certain age and stage at exactly the moment I found your blog, well… it was just meant to be.
During the last nearly 3 years of growing out my grey, I have had nothing but encouragement and complements from fellow grandmothers and mothers waiting at the school gates, friends, family and even the old boy in the local grocery shop! All this has been a bonus. And this is because I found your brilliant website, armed myself with your honesty and great sense of humour and set out expecting to be met with shock and horror as I moved through the stages of looking as though I had let myself go, to looking completely bonkers, and now to somewhere near a complete revelation. It turns out I look exactly like my mother. A bit of a shock at first – but it seems that mother nature does know her stuff. Thank you Katie for helping me keep the faith!
so happy for you, both your natural hair and your change of residence…I’m American, but the west of England is my favorite place on Earth…I take the train to Penzance from Exeter every time I go to the UK.🏴🏴🏴
Katie:
Amen, I am glad you did the above video, I totally agree. I feel the same way you do about my gray hair, I chose to go gray and I love it as well and I am glad I did go gray. You go girl, you are so right, if other people want to go gray, then go gray, if they do not want to then they need to not comment on others that chose to go gray. I am so like you, I am totally happy with my gray hair, I have people tell me I look younger, so you go girl you are the greatest. God Bless, love your blogs and emails. Carol Duffert
The same thing has happened to me and the comments go the same depending upon what Generation you are friends with. In my circle of friends: Late 20s/Early 30s; Late 30s/Early 40s (my bff is the one that encouraged me should could help me and did as well as my husband), and our age: Late 40s/Early 50s. Late 20s: “Your hair looks cool! But, Why?” Late 30s: My hair was as dark as yours and I had more silver and grey so I just dye it blond.” (I’m tired of dying my hair and all the breakage and fall out etc). My age: “Wow! You look amazing! I’m just not brave enough, or my husband would leave me (mine has been trying to get me to do this for the past 5 years or so…so he’s been 100% on board with this decision and encouraging me, as well as, attracted to me exponentially to the point of me saying…”Holy cow, again?!”) Late/Early 50s: Welcome to the Silver club.
Bad stuff: At the gym the 20 year old told me that I could get my insurance to pay for my membership with the Silver Sneakers Club. (I was 48 at the time of this discussion)…I totally embarrassed her and said, “Well, mine won’t because I am not old enough to be in the Club. I know that you can see my DOB on my membership form there, right?!”
I’ve even explained to strangers that for me to transition to my hair was my want! I needed to do it for me and some days I miss my dark brunette hair. But most days, I don’t! I love it! I have hypothyroidism and so now, my hair is super healthy and doesn’t fall out near as much and it matches my skin tone perfectly! I don’t have dark stains on my forehead from spraying my roots and sweating etc etc etc and my scalp isn’t damaged and I don’t waste 2 hours out of my life every 2 weeks to dye it and in 3 shampoos it’s done!
I had the same experience when we first got our dog. Lots of unsolicited comments to my family when we walked him: “oh, he’s so cute; we can’t get a dog because…” and, like the gray hair comment, we never asked! It was so very interesting—and telling. Of course it speaks to the person’s own issues. Was an education for my kids and opportunity to talk to them about how language can unexpectedly reveal things about people. I get the same often with my new gray hair. Two things I’ve learned, have a voice about it but don’t judge. Society is conditioned to defy aging and most people buy into it. I certainly did for a long time by coloring my gray hair. So first off, I always correct the language and say “I’m not letting it GO gray (akin to letting yourself go and part of the conditioning language), I’m letting it BE gray because it already IS gray.” Then if I’m pushed further (almost always), I say: “I’m at peace with my age and my hair. It’s a new peace for me and honestly it feels great.” That’s it, gives the other person something to muse on.
Wow, Laura – those are great responses! You’ve definitely given me food for thought. I love the point about letting it BE gray because it already IS gray. Why did I never think of saying that? It’s fantastic! And I bet your words resonate with those people for quite some time after! And it’s kind too – you’re not being sarcastic or flippant. Lovely – thank you!